Home >> Learning Section

Sim Stanley
View Profile

Value Investing by PE Cut and Paste Will Nifty trade 13

From : Sim Stanley at 10:31 AM - Jan 31, 2011 ( )

Views: 11796

22 36 Bookmark

Let us see some analysis of current market conditions . Most of the people are rushing to buy now for long term . but this may not be a market to buy for long term . I am myself Bullish now , but for short term not long term .

I would not be surprised to see markets rise by over 10-15% more over next 1-2 months till the Budget . But sooner or later I expect

- A nice correction if this is another bull market .
- Bull rally coming to an end in the strong bear market 

The simple analysis is with a simple and strong tool called PE ratio. PE ratio tells us how expensive or cheap is the current underlying . In other words what kind of value does the market provide us , irrespective of the price .

Historically Nifty has been considered and shown instances of being oversold in range of 10-13 and overbought in range of 20-25 . Nifty has had a crash after after getting in the range of 20-25 and have rallied after touching the range of 10-13 .


Click to enlarge , Data for last 10 yrs (Jan 1999 – 31st May 2009)

You will see that whenever nifty crossed 20 , It was time to be cautious . its not exactly the time to go short sell , but at least book your partial profits and be cautious with further buying for long term .

Current situation : As I write this, Nifty PE is around 21 . Its not a very good situation to madly buy for long term . Its a time when euphoria is at high point and it can take markets a little further. So you can jump in now with short term perspective , not long term !!, because markets may fall in some weeks or months . Expect it . but dontforce it !! .

To get any future Posts , why not Subscribe to Get Posts in Email or RSS Reader

OVERSOLD MOMENTS in Indian Markets

Who all missed the current Rally ? I missed it . there are two reasons , I am a trader not an investor for long term (at least currently) . So I do not concentrate on it . But you could have not missed it if you had read this concept earlier and had the guts to go against the so called “experts on CNBC” who were talking about 5k or 6k for NIFTY some months back .

Click to enlarge , Data for last 10 yrs (Jan 1999 – 31st May 2009)


If you see the chart , you can see that after touching the PE levels of 11-13 , markets have rallied back as it was too oversold !! . Again , just touching these levels of PE does not signal a BUY , its only a signal to be cautious and make your mind for long side , and start the accumulation process without fear . Markets will still make lower levels and experts on CNBC will still cry over economy conditions and world coming to an end . But market rewards the “risk assumption” , not the actions on obvious facts . You also have to decide how much money of your portfolio would you like to put in stock market after considering your risk-appetite .

What can we learn from this PE Concept ?

“We can learn from history that we do not learn from History”

This is true for almost 95% of the long term investors all over the world . They do not learn things ,they do not do any research , they do not go and read blogs or tons of informational sites , they just want tips from others and make money . the mathematical expectation of that kind of investing is negative and cant work for long term. 
Lets develop a simple concept of PE based Investing . here it is

BUY Signal : Once PE crosses below 13 .

When NIFTY PE reached levels of 13 , start accumulating the stocks and invest your money in 4-5 installment over some months. Make sure that markets are going up and down andmoving in a range . If PE crosses below 11 , its a must BUY !!

SELL Signal : Once PE crosses above 20 .

Book the profit once NIFTY PE crosses above 20 , Don’t book all profits at once . Book it in parts . PE crossing above 20 does not mean markets has to fall , its only an indication that markets may be oversold and now “smart people” will starting selling there shares to mad public . Short sell the shares once PE and Markets start falling down from PE levels of 20 . If PE crosses above 25 , its a must SELL !!


There have been cases of PE going up to 25-28 levels . That will happen at the peak of strong bull markets like Jan 2008 . In very strong bull markets you have to understand that PE will cross even above or below its extreme points . That’s the risk part of stock markets from which not even GOD can save you from !! :) . this is the time when your buying in parts and putting capital which you can afford to loose will help !! .

Anyone who puts 100% of there money in stock market at once on one single time on a single bet has a secret affair with financial disaster which he/she himself is not aware of . So dont put all your money at once . Only put a part of your capital at any point .

Where do you get the PE data for Indices (Nifty and other Indices)

NIFTY data http://www.nseindia.com/content/indices/ind_histvalues.htm 

PE data : http://www.nseindia.com/content/indices/ind_pepbyield.htm

Note :

  • I have divided Nifty Value by 100 to make the graph look the way it is . In graphs , so on X axis if you see 40 , then read it as 4000 for nifty . but exact 40 for PE .
  • PE value will be separate for individual stocks as PE ratio for stock can go up or down for many other reasons . So if you are doing Stock analysis , see its historical PE values and find some pattern yourself . Innovate !!

From: Sim Stanley at 01:48 PM - Jan 20, 2013( )

19 PE reversal

checking this chart clearly states that Nifty reaches the top when it is trading at 19-20 PE

This way of reversal has been happening since Jun-11 and continued till date, a fresh breakout above 20 PE is required for the Bull rally to continue

so a new all time High needed to sustain the bull run?

From: Sim Stanley at 08:25 PM - Jul 22, 2014( )

PE return

In Reply to above Message (1 to 20 out of 119) - Latest Replies are put on Top | First | << Previous | Next >> | Last |

From : Sim Stanley at 01:34 PM - Dec 29, 2017 ( )

take the profits and be with trend to be on safe side

when everyone says buy u sell when everyone sell u buy

From : Rakesh Padhi at 03:44 PM - Nov 11, 2017 ( )

take it when market is giving...no need to be worried about PE..it's only CE for time being cool.....think about PE only when market breaks the trendline support....probably found a good support and flight ready for a take off. 

From : Sim Stanley at 12:54 PM - Nov 11, 2017 ( )

we are still in SELL territory with 26+ pe  indian index does not stay at this PE for long time

I expect a consolidation to form top if modi can keep giving positive news till Dec-17

From : Moses Samuel at 12:41 PM - Sep 13, 2017 ( )

Any P/E Ratio....

For the period 31-08-2017 to 13-09-2017

From : Sim Stanley at 12:37 PM - Sep 13, 2017 ( )

now all are talking about the PE of nifty  time to sell?


From : Sim Stanley at 09:57 AM - Aug 01, 2017 ( )

we are in sell territory all the results are getting discounted

For the period 31-07-2017 to 31-07-2017
Date P/E
31-Jul-2017 25.69

From : Sim Stanley at 01:29 PM - Jun 09, 2017 ( )

now the delima the index is moving up meanwhile the pe is moving down..

here we did not see the forward pe since index companies made more profit so the pe went down and share prices went up!

again we have to wait for pe to come to our sell area or buy area to take action

From : Sim Stanley at 06:57 PM - May 17, 2017 ( )

17-May-2017 25.23

We are in sell territory

Sell on every rise

From : Sim Stanley at 09:52 AM - May 14, 2017 ( )

From : Ambrish Patel at 08:39 AM - Feb 20, 2017 3 months ago )

Tanks for warning. thia time it may go up to 28 to 30.


3 months passed till the PE is at 24 after the results PE got adjusted eventhough market moved up

From : Sim Stanley at 10:43 AM - Apr 04, 2017 ( )

broke new high still we are below the resistance

From : Ambrish Patel at 08:39 AM - Feb 20, 2017 ( )

Tanks for warning. thia time it may go up to 28 to 30.

From : Sim Stanley at 07:08 PM - Feb 19, 2017 ( )

24-25 pe will be sell area will it be in March?, if so will nifty sell off to break 19PE?

From : Sim Stanley at 04:53 PM - Feb 05, 2017 ( )

nifty PE resistance is 23.9 

current PE 23.29

From : Sim Stanley at 10:55 AM - Nov 02, 2016 ( )

01-Nov-2016 23.31

From : Sim Stanley at 07:10 PM - Jul 12, 2016 ( )

12-Jul-2016 23.37


From : Sim Stanley at 12:45 PM - Jul 03, 2016 ( )

Are the Global Markets Bullish to trade at 24-30PE??

as per the data globla markets still not avoided a recession and I don't see a reason for Nifty to trade at 24-30PE in July!!

Be Cautious on Long side

All opportunity to sell small caps should be used in July

From : R K at 02:17 PM - Jul 01, 2016 ( )

Sim ji, what is current market PE ?

From : Sim Stanley at 02:12 PM - Jul 01, 2016 ( )

market topped or not many small caps started lower circuit with only sellers!!

1 to 20 out of 119

Login to participate in discussion.


Recently Discussed Posts of Sim Stanley

Learning Section >> Value Investing by PE Cut and Paste Will Nifty trade 13 (121)

Learning Section >> NIFTY SUPPORT AND RESISTANCE (251)

Banking Sector >> Not a call Trial trade (98)

Media & Publishing >> paper trade margin very high risk very high (1)

Market Outlook >> Marsons May Fly (17)