yatheendradas c.k.
View Profile

Apex court stops govt from selling stake in Hind Zinc

Yatheendradas C.k. at 06:21 AM - Jan 20, 2016 ( ) Views: 341

Apex court stops govt from selling residual stake in Hindustan Zinc



Questioning the government’s “hurry” to divest its remaining stake in Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL), the Supreme Court on Tuesday directed the Centre to put on hold a plan to offload its 29 per cent share in the erstwhile public sector unit, now a subsidiary of Vedanta.

Majority stake in HZL, which deals with strategic minerals, was first divested to Vedanta in 2003. “What is the hurry to hand over valuable assets worth lakhs of crores? Without permission of the court, you can’t go for disinvestment,” a Bench led by Chief Justice TS Thakur told the government, represented by Attorney-General Mukul Rohatgi.

Chief Justice Thakur insisted on status quo in the Hindustan Zinc disinvestment, while advising the government against bowing out of HZL. “Don’t do this and don’t go for the disinvestment. We will hear the matter. We will not allow you to sell,” Thakur said.

When Vedanta counsel and senior advocate CA Sundaram pointed out that HZL was a loss-making unit when his client took it over a decade-and-a-half ago and now the company has been transformed into a profitable venture, Thakur responded: “Yes, it was once loss-making and today it is making profit. So let the government also make some profit.”

The court made it clear that the restraint was not meant as a roadblock for Vedanta’s operations in HZL, but only a pause on the government’s plans to sell its residual stake till the court finally decides on the issue.

‘Illegal, arbitrary’

The Bench took serious note of a submission made by advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for petitioner National Confederation of Officers’ Associations of Central Public Sector Undertakings, about alleged violations of law in the first disinvestment.

“Already there are allegations of you having committed a wrong and we would not allow a second transgression,” the court told the government.

The petition has alleged the proposed disinvestment to be “illegal, mala fide and arbitrary.”

‘Policy decision’

When pressed for the reason behind the move to disinvest, Rohatgi maintained that it was a policy decision. “What is the compulsion for you to disinvest? You can’t do this without amending the law as the company was formed as an Act of Parliament,” the court said, even as the Attorney-General submitted that parliamentary sanction was not required for disinvestment.

(1 to 1 out of 1) - Latest Replies on Top | First | << Previous | Next >> | Last |
Yatheendradas C.k. at 06:24 AM - Jan 20, 2016 ( )

Hind Zinc divestment: delay to have little impact on stakeholders





The Supreme Court’s decision to ‘put on hold’ government’s plan for the residual stake sale in Hindustan Zinc, changes little for stakeholders.

On Tuesday, the apex court was hearing a plea filed by the National Confederation of Officers’ Association, an employee union against the planned divestment.


“As regards the impact on the Sesa Sterlite share price, we feel it is neutral. There was no expectation of a stake-sale any time soon,” a Mumbai-based analyst tracking the company told BusinessLine.

Said a senior Finance Ministry official, “It has been off the Budget for this fiscal. We can only go ahead with the stake-sale in HZL after the court ruling and we did not target any revenue from these.”

Vedanta awaits info

While the government had not targeted any revenue from the stake-sale in this fiscal, Anil Agarwal’s Vedanta Group, the promoter of Hindustan Zinc, also did not expect any forward movement from the government.

Vedanta did not want to comment, but people in the know of the development indicated that the company has not heard from the government in recent months about the plan to move ahead with the residual stake-sale in HZL. The company has maintained that it is ready to offer market-determined price for the stake.

In February 2013, the government considered a proposal to use the offer-for-sale (OFS) route for selling its residual stake in Hindustan Zinc. This meant that not only Vedanta Resources, the majority stakeholder of the two companies, but also ordinary investors had to bid for shares.

1 to 1 out of 1

Login to participate in discussion.

Top Gainers

MCDOWELL HOLDINGS LTD. 19.80 3.30 (20.00%)
HATHWAY CABLE & DATACOM 32.50 5.40 (19.93%)
SOMI CONVEYOR BELT. LTD. 14.80 2.45 (19.84%)
DEN NETWORKS LTD 80.55 10.70 (15.32%)
INDUSTRIAL INV TRUST LTD 72.80 8.00 (12.35%)
THE MANDHANA RET VENT LTD 13.35 1.20 (9.88%)
63 MOONS TECHNOLOGIES LTD 99.00 7.55 (8.26%)
CINELINE INDIA LIMITED 35.75 2.65 (8.01%)
FLEXITUFF INTER LIMITED 13.95 0.95 (7.31%)
NAVIN FLUORINE INT. LTD 689.90 45.80 (7.11%)

Top Losers

HOUSING DEV & INFRA LTD 8.80 -2.20 (-20.00%)
CG POWER AND IND SOL LTD 11.85 -2.95 (-19.93%)
VAKRANGEE LIMITED 27.70 -6.30 (-18.53%)
SANGAM (INDIA) LTD 40.00 -8.00 (-16.67%)
PARAG MILK FOODS LTD. 142.50 -18.60 (-11.55%)
PARAMOUNT COMM LTD 8.85 -1.10 (-11.06%)
AKSH OPTIFIBRE LIMITED 6.55 -0.80 (-10.88%)
SHREYAS SHIPPING & LOGIST 72.00 -8.00 (-10.00%)
SUPERHOUSE LIMITED 70.85 -7.85 (-9.97%)
IND TERRAIN FASHIONS LTD 75.00 -8.15 (-9.80%)